Yesterday's post on the Glenn Beckert Scratch Off card led me to take a look at the checklist of the 24 card set. And that, in turn led me to the 1970 Booklets checklist. There are some similarities between the two. Both sets had 24 items with one player from each team. I thought it would be interesting to compare the two lists to see which has more star power. I was also curious if any big names got left off.
The checklists are shown below. The name in bold is the one I considered to be the bigger star of the two. My picks are totally subjective, based on the memories of an eight year old boy in 1970.
Scratch Off
| Team | Booklet
|
| Jim Spencer | Angels | Jay Johnstone |
| Sal Bando | A's | Reggie Jackson |
| Jim Wynn | Astros | Denis Menke |
| Hank Aaron | Braves | Orlando Cepeda |
| Rich Allen | Cardinals | Bob Gibson |
| Glenn Beckert | Cubs | Ernie Banks |
| Claude Osteen | Dodgers | Bill Singer |
| Mack Jones | Expos | Rusty Staub |
| Juan Marichal | Giants | Willie Mays |
| Sam McDowell | Indians | Vada Pinson |
| Tom Seaver | Mets | Cleon Jones |
| Boog Powell | Orioles | Mike Cuellar |
| Nate Colbert | Padres | Al Ferrara |
| Tim McCarver | Phillies | Deron Johnson |
| Mike Hegan | Pilots | Tommy Harper |
| Willie Stargell | Pirates | Bob Moose |
| Carl Yastrzemski | Red Sox | Rico Petrocelli |
| Tony Perez | Reds | Pete Rose |
| Lou Piniella | Royals | Wally Bunker |
| Dick Bosman | Senators | Mike Epstein |
| Al Kaline | Tigers | Bill Freehan |
| Harmon Killebrew | Twins | Tony Oliva |
| Luis Aparicio | White Sox | Walt Williams |
| Mel Stottlemyre | Yankees | Bobby Murcer
|
My list gives the advantage to the Scratch offs, 14-10. Agree?? Disagree?? Don't care??
There were some notable players, including a few Hall of Famers missing from both lists. Superstars like Johnny Bench, Ron Santo, Roberto Clemente, Rod Carew, Phil Niekro, Willie McCovey, Frank Robinson, Lou Brock, and Frank Howard were not on either list. Why?

Because they were on the 1970 Posters checklist; which also had 24 players, one per team. I just bought the Ron Santo poster, and when it comes, I'll throw the poster checklist up and we can see which of the three was the overall winner.
I've been gradually picking up some of the inserts from Topps sets of the late '60s and early '70s.
This is a Scratch Off card from 1970 that features Cubs second baseman Glenn Beckert. There were only 24 of these in the set, with one player per team. It's interesting that Topps picked Beckert as the Cubs player. As far as star ranking on the team, he would probably rank 5th or 6th, behind Ernie Banks, Billy Williams, Ron Santo, and Fergie Jenkins.
I do remember getting these, but I don't think I ever had the Beckert card.
The game on the inside was pretty simple. You would just scratch off a square and keep track of what happened. Each player had his own card, and you hoped you scratched off enough hits to score a run before you scratched three outs.

There are 44 plays on the card. I counted the different results:
There were 27 out squares:
7 - Strike Out
7 - Ground Out
6 - Fly Out
3 - Foul Out
3 - Double Play
1- Sacrifice
Players reached base on 17 of the squares
8 - Single
3 - Double
1- Triple
2 - Home Run
1 - Error
2 - Walk
This is the only one of these cards that I've got so I'm not able to check, but I'd guess that each card had 27 outs on it....you need that many for a complete game. I wonder if some had a different number of singles, doubles, triples, and homers. Anyone else got one of these to check?
I've got 9,446 Cubs cards from 59 different brands listed on a spreadsheet. A random number generator picked five cards, one each from the past several decades.

1950s / 1960s: 1955 Bowman #229 Jim Brosnan Yea! The TV set! Brosnan pitched in 18 games as a rookie in 1954 and that was good enough for Bowman to include him in the '55 set. But it wasn't good enough for the Cubs to include him on their '55 roster. Instead, he spent the season in the minors and had a great year, going 17-10 with a 2.38 ERA. After the '55 season he would never pitch in the minors again. I never knew Brosnan as a pitcher. Instead, to me he was the author of this book...

...which I got when I was seven or eight and became a favorite of mine. Two Cubs, Ron Santo and Rich Nye, were among the little leaguers who became big leaguers.

1970s: 1976 Topps #334 Mike Garman This is a nasty looking card, with the scowl on Garman's face and a really bad airbrush job. Garman came to the Cubs from the Cardinals for Don Kessinger. With that trade, the final member of the '69 Cubs was gone. Garman had a horrible season in 1976, with a 2-4 record and 4.95 ERA out of the bullpen. After the season he was sent to LA in the trade that brought Bill Buckner to the Cubs.

1980s: 1989 Team Issued #33 Mitch Webster These cards were given away at Wrigley Field on August 10, 1989. The Cubs had just taken over first place three days earlier, on their way to the NL East crown. They lost to the Phillies on Baseball Card Day in a slugfest, falling 16-13. The Cubs blew a 10-3 3rd inning lead that day....oops! Webster went 1-5.

1990s: 1995 Leaf #163 Steve Trachsel The 1995 season was not a good one for Steve Trachsel as he suffered the dreaded Sophomore Slump. His record was 7-13 and his ERA was 5.15. Those are some horrible numbers! He did turn it around the next season, going 13-9 and lowering his ERA to 3.03.

2000s: 2009 T206 #208 Derrek Lee D-Lee had his last hurrah for the 2009 Cubs, putting up his best numbers since his career-best season in 2005. For 2009 he hit 35 HRs and drove in 111 runs while hitting .306. Topps wasn't too impressed with what Lee was doing, because his T206 card is just a recycled...

....2009 Allen and Ginter card.
I picked up a complete set of 33 Cognac Cubs on October 10. I got them from a very popular dealer, someone I've bought from many times before. He shipped the cards the next day, and the USPS tracking showed the cards were at his local post office. I figured that I'd have the cards by the 14th or 15th at the latest. So I went ahead and wrote yesterday's post on the Hall of Fame Cognac Cubs (which came from other dealers) last weekend, which is when I write a lot of my posts. The Hall of Famers were scheduled for the 20th and I started working on this post and scheduled it for today, the 21st. I figured that would give me plenty of time to get the cards delivered and then scanned in.
Well, I figured wrong. For an entire week the USPS tracking showed the cards were still at the dealer's post office. So on the 18th I email him. He got back to me the next day and said that he recently sent out 700 packages and had a problem with a couple. Lucky me, mine was one of them. He also said the post office would look into my missing cards. Now I was getting nervous. I could schedule another post for today, but I really didn't want to have to get all of the cognac cards from a slew of dealers.
Low and behold, on the 20th the USPS tracking info changed and it showed that the cards were now at my areas large distribution center! What once was lost has now been found!. The cards came yesterday. I scanned them in right away and got today's post finished up.
I decided not to show the cards individually, since you've already got a look at them in the base and sparkly versions. Instead, I made a collage of all 33 together. This way you get the full effect of the cognac. After all, what's the point of having some cognac if your not going to get the full effect. Cheers!

I needed to take a break from the Update stuff, so I grabbed my '50s Cubs binder. The plan was to page through until a card drew my attention. A 1953 card did, and along the way I learned a couple interesting things about a player I never really knew.
Here's the card...

...of pitcher Turk Lown. It was the autograph that caught my eye, because '53s have an autograph on the back, not the front. The one on the front is the real deal. Well, according to the seller on ebay its the real deal. Honestly, I had forgotten about this signed card. When I was putting my '53 set together, the Lown was one of the last cards I needed. I saw the auction for this one, and I decided to see just how high it would go for. It didn't go for much at all. In fact, I was the only bidder and the price was only a buck or two more than a regular card. I figured, why not, and got it.

If you compare the signature on the front with the one on the back, you can see that they are pretty similar. I also wonder if anyone would bother to create fake Turk Lown cards. Mantle, yes; Mays or Williams, sure. But probably not Turk Lown.

Now look again at the signature part on the back. But this time, ignore the signature and read the back. Turk was an accidental pitcher, and he ended up in the major league. Plus, he's a hero, a Purple Heart vet wounded at the Battle of the Bulge.
Does it seem to you that players from the '50s had far more interesting stories and lives than modern players? And more interesting nicknames too.
And if you're wondering about his nickname, here's the story: Being a low-paid minor leaguer, he would often eat only once a day. His menu choice was the biggest meal on the menu, usually turkey. Eat a lot of turkey, get a nickname, Turk.