Jimmie Schaffer was born in 1936. The card is from 1963, so the picture is probably from 1962, Schaffer would have been 26 years old. He looks 40.
Ernie Broglio was born in 1935 and the picture on the card is from 1964. The guy was just 29. He too looks 40.
Born in the Depression, kids during the war. Did stressful times age them prematurely?
Because kids from the 50's and 60's don't have that same look. Tom Veryzer was 30 when this picture was taken. He looks like he's 12 and should be playing with the Bad News Bears.