Saturday, May 18, 2019

The Second Best Game Ever

I should have posted this yesterday, but forgot.

Below is a post from ten years and a day ago.  It's my account of the Cubs 23-22 loss to the Phillies on May 17, 1979.  When I wrote the post I used the title "The Best Game Ever."  And it was the best game I'd ever been to.  I now rank it #2, behind the Cubs win in game 1 of the NLCS.  

Enjoy my take on the second best game I've ever attended:

Thirty years ago I was lucky enough to be at Wrigley Field for one of the best Cubs games, ever. On May 17, 1979, the Cubs lost to the Phillies in ten innings by the score of 23-22. Yep, you read that right, 23-22. It was an amazing game.

Photo of the scoreboard from the New York Times website

My story...

I was a senior in high school in 1979 and we picked May 17 as our senior ditch day. Several of us planned an outing to the bleachers at Wrigley Field. Getting tickets to a game was so much easier back then. This was before Wrigley had lights, so tickets to weekday games in April and May were a snap to get. The bleacher tickets were $1.50 and sold only on the day of the game (today they are $60 and sell out the first day they are available in February). We arrived at the park around 11:30 and got right in. We settled in the right field bleachers in about the fifth row.

I don't remember it being that windy, but the wind definitely was blowing out. The game saw a total of eleven home runs, which tied the record for most home runs in a game. Mike Schmidt hit two and Dave Kingman hit three!

Mike Schmidt, two dingers, Dave Kingman, three

The first inning set the stage for the entire day. Cubs starter Dennis Lamp lasted only 1/3 of an inning was was tagged for six runs. His relief Donnie Moore gave up a home run to Phillies starter Randy Lerch and before the Cubs even came to the plate they were down 7-0.

Lerch's home run was the highlight of his day, because he too lasted only 1/3 of an inning. Kingman hit his first homer of the day in the first as the Cubs scored 6 runs and trailed 7-6.

The two starting pitchers, each lasting on 1/3 of an inning.

The second inning was a rarity, one in which both teams failed to score. But the Phillies put an 8 spot on the Cubs in the top of the third and just like that the Cubs were behind by nine runs! The Cubs did not answer the Phillies like they did in the first, going scoreless in the third.

The Phillies kept their run parade going in the fourth as they added two more runs, but the Cubs answered with three in the bottom of the inning as Kingman and Steve Ontiveros hit back to back homers. But the score was 17-9 and Cubs were still down by 8.

The top of the fifth saw four more Phillies cross the plate and when the Cubs came up in the bottom of the fifth, they trailed 21-9. Usually when your team scores nine runs in the first four innings you feel pretty good. We didn't feel good. We were trying to decide how much longer to stick around at the park.

Well, the bottom of the fifth helped us decide to stay awhile longer. The Cubs put a seven spot on the board and narrowed the gap to five, 21-16 The highlights of the inning were a two run shot by Kingman (his second of the day) and a grand slam by Bill Buckner. Buckner's shot landed close to where we were sitting. I've watched replays of the game, looking for myself, but there was never a good enough shot to see me.

And when the Cubs scored three more in the bottom of the sixth as Kingman hit his third home run, they were within two runs. Wrigley Field went crazy. The Phillies added one in the top of the seventh and when the Cubs came up in the bottom of the eighth, they trailed 22-19. Five singles later, the game was tied! The Cubs had come back from a 12 run deficit to tie the game. It was absolutely the craziest thing I have ever seen.

Bullpen ace Bruce Sutter came in to pitch the ninth and got the Phillies out pretty easily. It was on to the bottom of the ninth, and as announcer Jack Brickhouse would say, "Any old kind of a run wins." Unfortunately. the Cubs went 1-2-3. It was on to extra innings. This was the first time since the second inning that an inning was scoreless.

Sutter again was on the hill in the tenth and got three easy outs. But squeezed between the outs was a monster home run by Mike Schmidt to give the Phillies the lead. Now when the Cubs batted in the bottom of the tenth, it was score or go home. And Dave Kingman was going to be up second in the inning. We were sure good things would happen. We were wrong! Kingman struck out as the Cubs again went down 1-2-3. The game was over and the Phillies won, 23-22.

Rawly Eastwick picked up the win, Sutter took the loss

Wow! What a game, what a day. Even though the Cubs lost, it felt like they won. How can you not feel good about a game in which you wipe out a 12 run deficit. The game tied the record for most home runs in a game and the 97 total bases set a record.

My very messy scorecard ended up looking like this:

The attendance for the game was 14,952. I've got the ticket stub, the scorecard, and the memories and I proudly say that I was one of the 14,952 to witness history!


  1. One of things that annoys me most while keeping score is when 10 or more batters come to the plate. Having to renumber the following innings just makes things look messy and unorganized. I thought it happening in the 1st inning was the worst... but then I saw your scorecard. It happened in the 1st inning for BOTH teams! Argh!

  2. You kept the scorecard and ticket stub? That's so awesome! I never truly learned how to fill out a scorecard myself, but I do with I kept all of my sports and concert ticket stubs from my youth.

    P.S. Fantastic game! The greatest game I ever attended was a soccer game... but it was a classic. If you're bored:

  3. I remember that game, the Wind was really blowing out of Wrigley that day.

  4. I love the story (told by Bowa) where we was standing on first and told Buckner "Ok, I think we have enough now" when they had a huge lead. As Buckner rounded second on his grand slam trot he asked Bowa "Still think you've got enough?"

  5. Very cool that you kept everything! Were you collecting cards back then?

    1. To clarify, were the cards shown from your collection at the time?

    2. Yes, I was buying complete sets from Renata Galasso.

  6. I'm telling Mom you ditched school!!

  7. I asked Baseball Reference and they confirmed...this was the only recorded game in which a relief pitcher (Donnie Moore) TRIPLED in the FIRST INNING.

  8. I was listening to that game on the radio.