1980s: 1989 Fleer Glossy #432 Jamie Moyer Moyer never played for the '89 Cubs. He had been traded to the Rangers the previous winter in the Mitch Williams / Rafael Palmiero deal.
1990s: 1992 Fleer Lumber #L4 Ryne Sandberg Ryon did bring out the lumber in 1992, smashing 26 homers, good for sixth in the league
2000s: 2009 Topps Chrome #19 Rich Harden Harden was just a .500 pitcher in 2009, going 9-9 with and ERA of 4.09.
2010s: 2013 Heritage Baseball Flashback #EB Ernie Banks The card references a game in September, 1964 (see the Tribune article on the game here), when the Cubs scored 8 runs in the second inning against the Cardinals. Ernie led off the frame with a home run and later added a two run double. The Cubs won the game 8-5. However, the game was in St. Louis, while the card shows Ernie in his home uniform.